Skip to content
Joy.so
Program design

New Customer Accounts: Every Past Buyer Already Has One

Shopify removed account registration. Joy, Smile and Yotpo now each define a loyalty member differently, and your numbers moved.

Thomas NguyenThomas Nguyen
Dark card reading New customer accounts
7 min read

Summarize this post with AI

Ask three loyalty apps how many members a store has and, on Shopify's current customer accounts, you will get three different numbers. Smile counts a customer once she has signed in with a code while Smile's content was on the page. Yotpo can count her from the moment Shopify creates her profile at guest checkout. Joy, by default, counts her when Shopify verifies her email, which can follow from a newsletter form.

None of the three is miscounting. Each is answering a question that used to have one obvious answer and no longer does.

Key Takeaways

  • On Shopify's current customer accounts there is no registration step. Shopify states that a customer with a profile in your admin already has an account.
  • Loyalty apps used account creation as the moment someone became a member. With that moment gone, Joy, Smile and Yotpo each define a member differently.
  • The definitions change your numbers. Under Joy's default, a newsletter subscriber whose email Shopify has verified is a member. Under Smile's, a buyer is not one until she signs in while Smile content is on the page.
  • Sign-up rewards, anniversary rewards, account-status segments and referral eligibility all depended on the old event and behave differently now.
  • Legacy accounts were deprecated on 26 February 2026 with no sunset date announced by 13 October. Switching account systems is not a job for BFCM week.

Published 18 November 2026. Platform and vendor behaviour was read from Shopify's, Joy's, Smile's and Yotpo's own documentation on 13 October 2026 and is linked. LoyaltyLion and Rivo were not read for this page.

The event Shopify removed

On legacy accounts a customer registered: an email address, a password, an activation. That was a moment with a timestamp, and loyalty apps hung membership on it.

The current system has no such moment. Shopify's guide to customer accounts states it directly: "If your customer has a customer profile in your Shopify admin, then they already have an account". Signing in means entering an email address and receiving "a one-time 6-digit verification code", and if the address is unknown, "a new customer profile is created automatically". Everyone who has ever ordered from you as a guest has an account they have never opened.

Shopify made this the direction of travel on its own timetable. Its changelog entry of 26 February 2026 reads: "Legacy customer accounts are no longer available to new stores and existing stores not using it", with a final sunset date to "be announced later in 2026". The developer changelog's version of the same notice says apps can reach "over 70% of Shopify merchants (and growing) already using customer accounts".

Timeline of Shopify's customer accounts change from the 2023 rollout to the deprecation of legacy accounts in February 2026
No sunset date had been announced on 13 October 2026.

For seven stores in ten, on Shopify's figure, this has already happened. What does not follow automatically is anyone re-reading what the loyalty numbers mean afterwards.

Three vendors, three definitions of a member

App and modeA customer becomes a member whenWelcome reward
Joy, auto-enroll (default)Shopify marks the customer's email verified. Newsletter subscribers includedOnce per customer, on joining through a standard path
Joy, customer opt-inShe clicks Join ProgramOn joining
SmileShe signs in with the 6-digit code and Smile content loads while she is signed inNot stated on the page
Yotpo, all customersA Shopify customer profile is created, including at guest checkout or email signupAfter the first purchase as a member
Yotpo, only members who signed upShe signs in and clicks the opt-in buttonImmediately on opting in
Table of how Joy, Smile and Yotpo each define a loyalty member on Shopify's new customer accounts
One store and five possible member counts.

Joy's default is the widest. Under Auto-enroll, Joy's guide to member enrollment says "a customer becomes a Member as soon as Shopify marks their email verified. That includes newsletter subscribers". Merchants who want intent instead switch to Customer opt-in, on the Advanced and Ultimate plans, where customers "stay Guests until they click Join Program".

Smile's is the narrowest. In Smile's article on Shopify's new customer accounts, "A customer becomes a Member only when both of the following happen": she logs in with the verification code, and "Smile content loads while they are logged in". A customer who buys five times as a guest is not a member on that definition.

Yotpo offers both ends, as its guide to using Yotpo Loyalty with new customer accounts sets out. With eligibility set to all customers, "customers are enrolled in your loyalty program automatically when a Shopify customer profile is created, for example, during checkout (including guest checkout) or through an email signup". With members who signed up, the customer logs in and then clicks to join.

What depended on the old event

The welcome reward

Points for creating an account made sense when creating an account was something a person did. Yotpo's page on new customer accounts states the consequence: "The New Member Reward now triggers after the first purchase, not on signup". Joy keeps a sign-up reward and limits it: its member enrollment guide says the reward is "granted once per customer, ever", and only when she joins through a standard path, so "a migration or bulk import won't mass-award points".

The enrolment rate

If membership now includes every verified email address, the enrolment rate rises without anybody's behaviour changing. A store that moved account systems during the year cannot compare this November's member sign-ups with last November's. The two figures count different things.

Anniversaries and account-status segments

Yotpo's documentation for new customer accounts notes that "Anniversary rewards based on account creation are no longer supported". Shopify's guide to upgrading from legacy customer accounts lists two more casualties: segments using customer_account_status "won't work as expected after you upgrade", and workflow triggers built on legacy accounts "can't be migrated". A win-back flow that targeted customers who had never activated an account has nothing to select on.

Who counts as new for a referral

Referral programs reward bringing in someone new. Joy's article explaining the referral flow describes the referee as a new customer "who must not have an existing account". Where every profile is an account, it is worth reading how your own app decides that, because a friend who once subscribed to your newsletter is not obviously new.

How a member signs in from the widget

Login shortcuts built on the old system do not carry over. Joy's guide to customer login within the loyalty widget sets out what works where: the widget supports Sign in with Shop on both account systems, while its email code, Google and Facebook methods need Shopify Plus with legacy accounts and are hidden otherwise. The background to that is in frictionless login with Shop and email OTP.

The prompt you cannot switch off

One piece of the new sign-in experience is outside a merchant's control. If Shop Pay is active, a customer with a Shop account sees a sign-in prompt when she browses or checks out, and Shopify's guide to Shop sign-in features is plain about the choice: "If you want to remove the sign-in prompt for all customers, then the only option is to deactivate Shop Pay".

For a loyalty program that prompt is mostly an advantage. A customer who accepts it is recognised, and a recognised customer sees her balance and her tier. Shopify's page on customer accounts says sessions on the current accounts "persist for up to 365 days". Yotpo's page gives 90 days for the same thing, which is a reminder that vendor documentation trails the platform.

Not a November job

If your store is still on legacy accounts, leave it there until the new year. Shopify's upgrade guide for customer accounts says "You can revert within 30 days", and that is a safety net. It is not a reason to change how every customer signs in during the heaviest week of the year.

And if your program already enrols by an explicit opt-in button, most of this page describes other people's problem. Your member list meant the same thing before and after.

What to check instead

  • Which account system the store is on, in Settings, Customer accounts.
  • Which enrolment mode your loyalty app is in, and what it counts as a member.
  • Whether the welcome reward still fires, and on what.
  • Any segment or flow that uses customer_account_status.
  • How your referral program decides that a referee is new.
  • Whether your member count is comparable with the figure you reported after last BFCM.

Where the program itself now sits inside Shopify's account pages is covered in your loyalty program inside the customer's Shopify account.

Sort by join date

The three apps at the top of this page would give three numbers for one store. Find out which number yours is giving you. Open the member list in your loyalty app, sort it by join date, and look at who joined on the last day you ran a newsletter signup campaign.

FAQs

Do customers need to create an account on Shopify's new customer accounts?

No. Shopify's documentation on customer accounts says "If your customer has a customer profile in your Shopify admin, then they already have an account", and signing in with an unknown email address creates a profile automatically.

When will legacy customer accounts be switched off?

Shopify deprecated them on 26 February 2026 and said in the changelog entry announcing the deprecation that a final sunset date "will be announced later in 2026". No date had been announced when this page was written on 13 October 2026.

Why did my member count jump after switching account systems?

Because the definition of a member changed. Joy's documentation on member enrollment addresses the case directly: a newsletter subscriber with a verified email showing as a Member is "expected, not a bug".

Do sign-up points still work?

They work differently by vendor. Yotpo moved its New Member Reward to after the first purchase. Joy grants its sign-up reward once per customer, when she joins through a standard path, and not on an import or background sync.

Can I remove the Sign in with Shop prompt?

Only by turning off Shop Pay. The wording in Shopify's page on Shop sign-in features is that "the only option is to deactivate Shop Pay".

Should I upgrade from legacy accounts before Black Friday?

No. Shopify allows a revert within 30 days, but an account system is not something to change in the week your store is busiest. Plan it for January.

Thomas Nguyen

Written by

Thomas Nguyen

Thomas Nguyen is the CEO & Co-founder of Joy, a loyalty solution for Shopify and eCommerce brands. With years of experience building high-performance Shopify apps, Thomas aims to help merchants grow through customizable and retention-focused tools.

Stop being ordinary. Start leading

10,000+

Brands run loyalty on Joy

4.9

Shopify App Store rating

1,789

Merchant reviews